Who will decide that I’m an expert? Four answers from four worlds of the Future Decoder method. They come from participants of the scenario games, not from experts.

Autopilot world (CS)

the system decides, the result is not yours

An algorithm, by results.

  • How it develops: I’m assessed by an algorithm, on results, not knowledge. What matters is not what you learned but what changed after you.
  • The price: Ratings everywhere, and sometimes you want to go where you’re at zero.
  • Signal: Public procurement reports are no longer about delivering equipment to a hospital, but about doctors having learned to use it so many times.
  • Heard at the game: “The result matters more than process statistics”
  • Step for this week: Count the result your work gave others this month, not how many hours it took.

Rules world (CE)

you take part by shared rules

A community, through an exam and recognition.

  • How it develops: An expert is someone the community has recognised: passed the exam, completed the track, got the mentor’s approval. The rules are clear to everyone.
  • The price: Recognition doesn’t depend on you.
  • Signal: Since 1870 the British civil service has recruited through competitive exams.
  • Heard at the game: “The norm is the exam, it’s the pass”
  • Step for this week: Find a community or guild for your profession and learn what counts as recognition there.

Autonomy world (DS)

you decide and you own it

You yourself, by your own criteria.

  • How it develops: I set my own criteria: feedback, income, fit with my values and a sense of happiness. And I show publicly what I can do.
  • The price: If the world doesn’t share your criteria, you’ll be an expert only for yourself.
  • Signal: One after another, experts are building their own sites: knowledge bases with their methods and thoughts on the future.
  • Heard at the game: “If he invented his own grading system and meets it, does that mean the world also thinks he’s an expert?”
  • Step for this week: Write down five criteria of expertise for yourself and check yourself against them right now.

Community world (DE)

you create together with others

The people around you, by what has changed.

  • How it develops: You can tell an expert by how they handle the live tasks of people around them. It’s not you being assessed, but what changed nearby.
  • The price: Recognition comes slowly and quietly.
  • Signal: Metaculus: a site where people forecast the future and everyone’s accuracy is visible to all.
  • Heard at the game: “The environment tells us whom it needs”
  • Step for this week: Ask two people you work with what changed thanks to you.

Source: “Knowledge and Education” cycle: games of 31 Oct and 4 Nov 2026 (CS). Draft of the Future Decoder knowledge base, updated after every game. All questions