How will an ordinary person be able to influence taxes? Four answers from four worlds of the Future Decoder method. They come from participants of the scenario games, not from experts.
Autopilot world (CS)
the system decides, the result is not yours
You influence by withdrawing the base: business with people instead of computation.
- How it develops: If digital operations are taxed, live labour and real business without AI get cheaper: they’re harder to count. The entrepreneur keeps autonomy and some data to themselves. The state sees the base shrinking, and that’s the signal.
- The price: This is influence by exit, not dialogue. Tax authorities respond with new rules: registering computers, a tax “for optimisation”.
- Signal: After complaints, a region cut the cost of a business patent by 20%, and even more in poor districts (a participant’s example).
- Heard at the game: “Singe their base a little”
- Step for this week: Think which of your processes could work without a digital trail and what that would cost.
Rules world (CE)
you take part by shared rules
You can have influence, but not alone, and starting at the local level.
- How it develops: At first participants discussed only how to protect themselves and didn’t believe the state could be influenced. The host reminded them: the state is the expression of the people’s will. What works is not the street but the local level: an association of entrepreneurs, an ally in government, a forum where decisions are made together with officials.
- The price: It takes critical mass and brave people. Out of twenty associations, maybe one will stick to the cause.
- Signal: A regional forum was organised by about five small entrepreneurs (one has three plumbing shops); they brought in a senator and a deputy governor and discussed taxes (according to the host).
- Heard at the game: “We can raise your KPI”
- Step for this week: Find an association of entrepreneurs in your region and go to one of its events.
Autonomy world (DS)
Nobody has designed this world for this question yet.
Community world (DE)
you create together with others
You influence through mutual help and knowledge.
- How it develops: Many businesses close not because of taxes but because of an outdated business model and lack of knowledge. Entrepreneurs team up: shared premises, advice, tax training. They offer the municipality one specific small thing that benefits both sides. “Vasya alone won’t survive, but Vasya and Petya together will.”
- The price: It’s slow and needs someone to take on the organising.
- Signal: A free three-week programme for business in the region: lectures, speakers, premises; “just registered and came” (a participant’s experience).
- Heard at the game: “Taxes are a collective story too”
- Step for this week: Find one entrepreneur nearby and come up with one thing that’s cheaper to do together.
Source: Game “The Tax System of the Future: Scenarios and Levers of Influence”: 9 Jul; the “compute tax” scenario was read first and its quadrant wasn’t named on the board; placed in CS by meaning (full automation and transparency). Draft of the Future Decoder knowledge base, updated after every game. All questions